---
title: "Irmo Fire District Seeks Ouster of Columbia Fire Chiefs"
url: https://www.hererockhill.com/2026/11/19/irmo-fire-district-settlement-columbia-fire-chiefs/
date: 2026-11-19T10:25:58-05:00
modified: 2026-11-19T10:25:58-05:00
author: "HERE Irmo"
categories: ["Public Safety"]
site: "HERE Rock Hill"
attribution: "HERE Rock Hill"
---

# Irmo Fire District Seeks Ouster of Columbia Fire Chiefs

> IRMO, S.C. — The Irmo Fire District has put a price on ending its part in the court fight over the 2023 death of one of its firefighters, and the price includes the jobs of Columbia's two top fire officials. In an offer of judgment filed this week, lawyers for the district asked that Columbia

*Source: [HERE Rock Hill](https://www.hererockhill.com/2026/11/19/irmo-fire-district-settlement-columbia-fire-chiefs/) — November 19, 2026 by HERE Irmo*

IRMO, S.C. — The Irmo Fire District has put a price on ending its part in the court fight over the 2023 death of one of its firefighters, and the price includes the jobs of Columbia’s two top fire officials.

In an offer of judgment filed this week, lawyers for the district asked that Columbia let go of its fire chief, Aubrey Jenkins, and Assistant Chief Anthony Holloway. The terms also call for the district to be repaid roughly $40,000 it has spent on legal fees and for both men to write public apologies.

Jenkins would apologize for claiming Irmo Fire employees gave false statements to investigators. Holloway would apologize for claiming Irmo assistant chief Sloane Valentino shaped a federal workplace safety agency’s findings on the fire.

Firefighter James Muller, 25, was killed in May 2023 when a burning apartment building in Columbia collapsed. His widow, Emma Muller, sued the city. Irmo was not a defendant in her original suit; Columbia pulled the district in with a third-party claim arguing Irmo should share any damages.

That federal review, made public in April 2025, pointed to poor communication, weak tracking of crews on scene and limited knowledge of how unstable the building was.

Columbia has 20 days to accept the offer or answer with terms of its own. If it says no, the case keeps moving toward a trial that could come by spring.
