Rock Hill, October 8, 2025
News Summary
Questions arise surrounding the conviction of Evan Hawthorne for the murder of retired officer Larry Vaughan in Rock Hill, as claims of police misconduct and jury tampering surface. Reports detail the challenges faced during the investigation, including withheld evidence and potential bias. The trial concluded with a guilty verdict, leading to concerns about fairness within the legal process.
Rock Hill, South Carolina – Allegations of Police Misconduct and Jury Tampering Surface in the Conviction of Evan Hawthorne for the Murder of Retired Officer Larry Vaughan
Allegations of police misconduct and jury tampering have emerged following the conviction of Evan Hawthorne for the murder of retired officer Larry Vaughan, whose body was discovered in his Rock Hill apartment in July 2021. Hawthorne, a college student and former Marine, was arrested just hours after Vaughan’s death and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole by a York County jury in 2025.
The case has drawn scrutiny as Hawthorne’s family argues that the investigation was marred by misconduct, including withheld evidence and conflicts of interest. The family contends that the investigation should have been conducted by an independent body, considering Vaughan’s close ties to the local law enforcement agencies.
Incident Overview
On the evening of July 23, 2021, Vaughan and Hawthorne met for the first time at Tattoo Brews in downtown Rock Hill. Both men were reported to be heavily intoxicated. Vaughan’s postmortem blood alcohol level was measured at 0.277%, significantly above the legal driving limit of 0.08% in South Carolina. Additionally, toxicology reports revealed that Vaughan had consumed an extremely high dose of Zoloft, further impairing his faculties.
Surveillance footage from the bar captured the two arguing and displaying aggressive behavior before leaving together. They entered Vaughan’s apartment shortly after midnight, where a struggle allegedly occurred provoked by Vaughan’s aggression. Hawthorne later confessed to striking Vaughan multiple times during the altercation.
Investigative Concerns
Complications emerged surrounding the crime scene, where more than 50 individuals accessed the apartment, potentially contaminating crucial evidence. A knife was reportedly found near Vaughan’s body; however, it was never logged or analyzed as part of the evidence. Investigators apparently neglected significant procedural steps, including proper DNA and fingerprint testing.
The way the case was handled has raised questions of bias. Allegations surfaced of jury tampering when an alternate juror reported being approached by a detective involved in the case during jury deliberations. This incident, combined with claims of mishandled evidence and missing vital test results, especially regarding the knife found near Vaughan, has led to serious legal and ethical inquiries.
Trial and Verdict
In presenting their case, prosecutors effectively constructed a narrative of premeditation, while the defense argued for self-defense, claiming Hawthorne acted in response to Vaughan’s aggression. Despite the defense’s arguments, the jury reached a guilty verdict in under an hour.
After the conviction, Hawthorne expressed regret for Vaughan’s death during his sentencing, and his family subsequently released a statement expressing concerns about fairness in both the investigation and the trial process. The case has garnered comparisons to other high-profile cases in South Carolina that have raised similar questions regarding the integrity of the justice system.
Conclusion
The allegations surrounding the conviction of Evan Hawthorne have stirred a debate about accountability in law enforcement and the judicial system. As investigations continue, the case serves as a reminder of the importance of transparency and fairness in legal proceedings.
FAQ
What happened to Larry Vaughan?
Larry Vaughan was found dead in his Rock Hill apartment in July 2021.
Who was arrested for Vaughan’s murder?
Evan Hawthorne, a college student and former Marine, was arrested within hours of Vaughan’s death.
What was the outcome of Hawthorne’s trial?
In 2025, a York County jury convicted Hawthorne of murder and sentenced him to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
What are the allegations surrounding the investigation?
Hawthorne’s family claims the investigation was tainted due to police misconduct, withheld evidence, and conflicts of interest.
What was Larry Vaughan’s condition the night he died?
Vaughan’s postmortem blood alcohol level was measured at 0.277%, and toxicology reports indicated he had an extremely high dose of Zoloft, contributing to severe impairment.
What issues arose regarding the trial process?
Issues of jury tampering surfaced when an alternate juror reported being approached by a detective involved in the case during deliberations.
Key Features Overview
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Incident | Larry Vaughan found dead in Rock Hill apartment, July 2021. |
| Arrest | Evan Hawthorne arrested within hours of death. |
| Conviction | Hawthorne convicted of murder in 2025, sentenced to life without parole. |
| Allegations | Misconduct, withheld evidence, conflict of interest by law enforcement. |
| Toxicology | Vaughan’s blood alcohol level: 0.277%, high Zoloft dose. |
| Trial Issues | Jury tampering allegations and mishandled evidence. |
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Trial Begins for Steffen Tidwell Jr. in Shooting Case
Tragic Shooting Incident Claims Life of Officer in Pennsylvania
Family of Convicted Murderer Questions Investigation Integrity
Public Skepticism Over Text Confessions Related to Assassination Case
Skepticism Surrounds Confession Texts in Assassination Case
Double Homicide in West Hempfield Township
Endangered Missing Person Advisory Issued for 15-Year-Old
Political Violence Escalates: A Growing Concern in America
York County Arrests Eleven Alleged Child Predators
South Carolina Community Mourns Missing Individuals
Additional Resources
- Herald Online: Police Misconduct Allegations
- Wikipedia: Police Misconduct
- Charlotte Observer: Hawthorne Conviction
- Google Search: Evan Hawthorne Conviction
- WSOCTV: Trial Delayed
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Jury Tampering
- WBTV: Chester County Deputy Convicted
- Google News: Evan Hawthorne
- QC News: Trial Underway
Author: STAFF HERE ROCK HILL
The ROCK HILL STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HERERockHill.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Rock Hill, York County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as the Come-See-Me Festival, Rock Hill Arts Festival, and motorsport events at the Rock Hill Velodrome. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Rock Hill Chamber of Commerce and the Culture & Heritage Museums, plus leading businesses in manufacturing and technology that power the local economy such as 3D Systems and Comporium. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREAiken.com, HEREBeaufort.com, HEREChapin.com, HERECharleston.com, HEREClinton.com, HEREColumbia.com, HEREGeorgetown.com, HEREGreenwood.com, HEREGreenville.com, HEREHiltonHead.com, HEREIrmo.com, HEREMyrtleBeach.com, HERENewberry.com, HERERockHill.com, and HERESpartanburg.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into South Carolina's dynamic landscape.
